Document: Robbins Hose Co. v. Baker, C.A. No. 2247-VCP, Parsons, V. C. (Del. Ch. Oct. 31, 2007)

The Court granted a motion of judgment on the pleadings, enjoining the order of an “Appeal Broad” of a non-stock fire company that reversed the decision of a “Trial Board” to expel a member of the fire company, where the Appeal Board conducted a plenary review of the facts, rather than reviewing the Trial Board’s findings for a “gross error of law”.  The Court, however, refused to affirm the Trial Board’s findings, instead holding that the member was entitled to another appeal of the Trial Board’s review.